Ms. Miñagorri sued the Archdiocese after her employment as a Catholic school principal ended. One of the counts in the lawsuit alleged retaliation under Florida's Whistleblower Act. The Archdiocese argued that the trial court did not have jurisdiction over that claim because of the constitutional guarantees of religious freedom. The trial court denied that motion but the Third District Court of Appeal overturned the trial court, agreeing with the Archdiocese. Ms. Miñagorri appealed the 3rd DCA's opinion to this Court, arguing that no religious issues were at stake in her lawsuit and thus the Constitution did not shield the Archdiocese.